Is It Cheaper To Raise Chickens Or Buy Eggs?

Free Ranging and Training Chickens...

“I’m considering raising chickens to save money on eggs, but I’m not sure if it’s actually cost-effective. Can you break down the costs and benefits? Is it really cheaper to raise chickens than just buying eggs from the store?” Thanks, Emily, Alberta, Canada.

Is It Cheaper To Raise Chickens Or Buy Eggs? A Comprehensive Cost Analysis

Hey Emily! Thanks for reaching out with such an interesting question. As someone who’s been raising chickens for years, I’m excited to share my insights and help you decide whether raising chickens or buying eggs is the more cost-effective option for you in Alberta.

The answer to this question isn’t as straightforward as you might think. There are numerous factors to consider, including initial setup costs, ongoing expenses, and potential benefits beyond just egg production. Let’s break it all down and see how the numbers stack up.

Initial Setup Costs for Raising Chickens

Before you can start collecting fresh eggs from your backyard, you’ll need to invest in some essential equipment and supplies. Here’s a rundown of the initial costs you might encounter:

  • Chicken coop: $200 – $2,000+
  • Fencing or run: $100 – $500
  • Feeders and waterers: $20 – $50
  • Heat lamp (for cold Alberta winters): $20 – $40
  • Nesting boxes: $30 – $100
  • Chicks: $3 – $5 per chick (minimum 3-4 chicks recommended)

As you can see, Emily, the initial investment can vary widely depending on the quality and size of the equipment you choose. If you’re handy, you might be able to build some of these items yourself to save money.

Ongoing Costs of Chicken Keeping

Once you’ve got your coop set up and your chicks settled in, there are several recurring expenses to consider:

  • Feed: $15 – $30 per month for a small flock
  • Bedding: $10 – $20 per month
  • Health care and supplements: $5 – $10 per month
  • Electricity (for heat lamp and lighting): $5 – $15 per month

These costs can fluctuate based on factors like the number of chickens you have, the type of feed you use, and your local climate. In Alberta, you might need to spend a bit more on heating during those cold winter months.

Egg Production and Value

Now, let’s look at the payoff. A healthy, well-cared-for hen can lay about 250-300 eggs per year. However, production can vary based on factors like breed, age, and season. In Alberta’s climate, you might see a decrease in egg production during the darker winter months.

Let’s do some quick math, Emily. If you have four hens, each producing an average of 250 eggs per year, that’s 1,000 eggs annually. The average price for a dozen free-range eggs in Alberta is around $6-$7. So, 1,000 eggs (about 83 dozen) would be worth approximately $498-$581 if purchased from a store.

The Cost Comparison

Now, let’s break down the costs over a five-year period, assuming you start with four chicks:

  1. Initial setup costs (mid-range): $500
  2. Ongoing costs: $35/month x 60 months = $2,100
  3. Total cost over 5 years: $2,600

Over the same five-year period, your four hens could produce about 5,000 eggs, valued at $2,490-$2,905 if store-bought.

At first glance, it might seem like raising chickens is slightly more expensive. However, there are several factors to consider that could tip the balance:

Additional Benefits of Raising Chickens

  • Quality and Freshness: Home-raised eggs are often fresher and of higher quality than store-bought eggs.
  • Organic Eggs: If you use organic feed, you’ll be producing organic eggs at a fraction of the store price.
  • Fertilizer: Chicken manure is an excellent fertilizer for your garden, potentially saving you money on store-bought fertilizers.
  • Pest Control: Chickens can help control insects and pests in your yard.
  • Educational Value: If you have children, raising chickens can be an excellent learning experience.
  • Potential Income: You might be able to sell excess eggs to neighbors or at local farmers’ markets.

Factors That Could Affect Cost-Effectiveness

Emily, keep in mind that several factors could influence whether raising chickens is cheaper for you:

  • Local Regulations: Check Alberta’s local laws regarding backyard chickens. Some areas might have restrictions or require permits.
  • Predators: In rural Alberta, you might need to invest more in predator-proofing your coop.
  • Time Investment: Caring for chickens takes time. If you value your time highly, this could tip the balance.
  • Veterinary Costs: Unexpected health issues could increase your costs.
  • Feed Prices: Fluctuations in grain prices can affect your ongoing costs.
  • Egg Prices: If egg prices rise significantly, raising chickens becomes more cost-effective.

Environmental Considerations

While not directly related to cost, it’s worth considering the environmental impact. Raising your own chickens can reduce packaging waste and transportation emissions associated with store-bought eggs. In Alberta, where sustainability is becoming increasingly important, this could be a significant factor in your decision.

The Intangible Benefits

Emily, it’s important to remember that not all benefits can be measured in dollars and cents. Many chicken keepers find joy and satisfaction in:

  • Knowing exactly where their food comes from
  • The companionship of their chickens (yes, they can be quite friendly!)
  • The pride of self-sufficiency
  • The unique flavors of truly fresh eggs
  • The rewarding experience of animal husbandry

These intangible benefits might outweigh any small financial differences for many people.

Strategies to Maximize Cost-Effectiveness

If you decide to raise chickens, here are some tips to make it more cost-effective:

  • Build your own coop using recycled materials
  • Grow some of your own chicken feed
  • Use deep litter method to reduce bedding costs
  • Supplement feed with kitchen scraps (safely)
  • Choose breeds known for good egg production
  • Consider selling excess eggs

Final Thoughts…

Emily, when it comes down to it, raising chickens in Alberta can be cost-competitive with buying eggs, especially when you factor in the additional benefits and potential for selling excess eggs. However, the true value often lies in the experience and quality of the eggs rather than pure financial savings.

If you’re passionate about fresh, high-quality eggs and enjoy the idea of urban homesteading, raising chickens could be a rewarding adventure for you. On the other hand, if you’re solely focused on saving money and don’t have the time or interest in chicken care, buying eggs might be the better option.

Thank you for bringing this question to me, Emily. It’s a topic I’m passionate about, and I hope this breakdown helps you make the best decision for your situation in Alberta. Whether you decide to raise chickens or stick to store-bought eggs, I wish you the best of luck. And if you do decide to take the plunge into chicken keeping, feel free to reach out with any more questions!

Whether you're a complete beginner and don't know where to start, or you're a seasoned chicken keeping professional and just want practical "how to" advice on tap our guide to keeping chickens has got you covered...

Chicken Keeping Book

Leave a reply

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}